Introduction Grounds for contested divorce in India
Contested divorce can be a complex and emotional journey, especially if one spouse does not agree to the divorce. In India, divorce can be contested on specific grounds outlined by the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and other religious personal laws. Understanding these grounds is crucial for anyone considering or facing a contested divorce. In this guide, we’ll cover the main grounds for filing a contested divorce in India, helping you navigate this challenging legal process.
1. Adultery
Definition: Adultery refers to voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and someone who is not their spouse. Under Indian law, it’s one of the leading grounds for contested divorce.
Proof Needed:
Direct evidence (often difficult to obtain) or circumstantial evidence such as:
Photographs
Communication records (texts, emails, etc.)
Statements from witnesses
Legal Considerations: While adultery is no longer a criminal offense in India, it remains a valid ground for divorce under Hindu law. However, the burden of proof is on the petitioner, and establishing adultery requires clear evidence of infidelity.
2. Cruelty
Definition: Cruelty can be physical or mental. Any act causing grave physical, mental, or emotional harm to the other spouse may qualify as cruelty.
Types of Cruelty:
Physical Cruelty: Domestic violence, assault, or bodily harm.
Mental Cruelty: Verbal abuse, humiliation, or severe psychological distress caused intentionally.
Examples of Evidence:
Medical records, if applicable
Witnesses to abusive behavior
Police or domestic violence reports
Legal Perspective: The courts have widened the definition of cruelty over time. Mental cruelty is often harder to prove, but consistent patterns of abusive behavior or verbal harassment can make a strong case.
3. Desertion
Definition: Desertion involves one spouse intentionally abandoning the other without reasonable cause for a continuous period of at least two years before filing the divorce.
Key Points:
The desertion must be intentional and without consent.
Desertion includes both physical separation and intent to end the marital relationship.
Proof Requirements:
Documentation or witnesses supporting the absence of the spouse
Evidence of lack of communication or support from the spouse
Legal Implications: Courts view desertion seriously, as it disrupts the fabric of the marriage. For a successful claim, the deserted spouse must show that the separation was not consensual and the intention to abandon was clear.
4. Conversion to Another Religion
Definition: Conversion to a different religion without the consent of the spouse can be a ground for divorce.
Proof Needed:
Certificate or statement from a religious authority confirming the conversion
Documentation of religious conversion ceremonies or practices
Court Perspective: Conversion disrupts the religious foundation of the marriage, making it valid grounds for divorce. If one spouse voluntarily converts to another religion and the other does not agree, the courts may grant divorce on this basis.
5. Mental Disorder or Incapacity
Definition: Mental disorders that make it difficult for one spouse to maintain the marital relationship can be grounds for divorce.
Types:
Severe Mental Illness: Conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or others that impair daily functioning.
Unfit for Married Life: Cases where mental incapacity prevents the spouse from fulfilling marital obligations.
Proof Requirements:
Medical records and psychiatric evaluations
Testimonies from mental health professionals
Court’s Approach: Indian law recognizes the challenges posed by mental illness in marriage. However, the illness must be severe and continuous for it to qualify as grounds for divorce.
6. Communicable Disease
Definition: If one spouse suffers from a communicable disease (like leprosy or an STD) that poses a risk to the other spouse’s health, it may be grounds for divorce.
Proof Needed:
Medical records confirming the diagnosis
Statements from doctors or health professionals
Court’s View: The spouse filing for divorce on these grounds must demonstrate that the disease poses a legitimate health risk. The court takes a compassionate stance but also considers the health and wellbeing of the unaffected spouse.
7. Renunciation of the World
Definition: Renunciation, or the act of giving up worldly life, can be grounds for divorce if one spouse decides to become a monk or nun, abandoning marital obligations.
Proof Requirements:
Statement from the religious institution
Evidence of the spouse’s decision to renounce worldly possessions and relationships
Legal Perspective: Indian courts grant divorce when one spouse formally renounces the world, as it represents a complete withdrawal from marital and societal responsibilities.
8. Presumption of Death
Definition: If a spouse has been missing for at least seven years and is presumed dead, the other spouse can file for divorce.
Proof Needed:
Documentation showing the spouse’s absence for seven years or more
Statements from witnesses who can testify to the spouse's disappearance
Legal Insight: The court may grant divorce on this ground to allow the petitioner to move on legally. The spouse’s absence must be continuous and without any communication to the petitioner or family.
Conclusion
Navigating a contested divorce is challenging, particularly when emotions and legal complexities are involved. Each ground for divorce comes with unique evidence requirements and legal implications, making it essential to consult an experienced divorce lawyer. At Adv. Dharmendra Chawla & Associates, we specialize in contested divorces, providing clients with comprehensive guidance on the grounds for divorce and tailored strategies to meet their specific needs. Contact us today to get the clarity and support you deserve.
Comments